Top 5 This Week

Related Posts

Cardano’s 22M ADA Copper Bet Is Running Out of Votes. The Money Isn’t Even the Biggest Problem

An account holding just 4.66 ADA could receive 22 million more from Cardano’s treasury.

The money hasn’t arrived. But the account already exists, its staking delegation is active, and the proposal that names it as the recipient is running out of support.

On November 7, two more delegated representatives voted against the plan. By November 8, only five DReps supported it, while 109 opposed it. Three members of Cardano’s seven-seat Constitutional Committee had also declared the proposal unconstitutional.

And voting would remain open for another week.

The project behind this unusual situation is Toto Finance, a U.S.-based company proposing to build a strategic copper reserve for Cardano. Its plan sounds like a familiar promise from the real-world asset industry: buy something tangible, verify that it exists, and put its economic representation on a blockchain.

But the deeper question isn’t whether blockchain technology can tokenize copper.

It’s why Cardano would release 22 million ADA into a structure where the company receiving the funds also administers them, crucial safeguards remain unfinished, and the token itself begins life on Ethereum.

The voting numbers suggest Cardano’s governance community has become increasingly uncomfortable with that arrangement.

The transaction hasn’t happened. The objections already have.

A Copper Reserve With Almost No Support

Toto Finance submitted its Cardano Strategic Copper Reserve proposal on October 15, requesting a one-time withdrawal of 22 million ADA.

The company wants to purchase COMEX Grade 1 copper cathodes, store them in an approved U.S. warehouse, and issue digital tokens called CuTT. Each token would economically represent one verified pound of copper.

The reserve would hold the metal for 18 to 24 months before selling it. Toto promises to return all net proceeds from the physical sale, along with unused or unearned funds, to Cardano’s treasury by the end of month 36.

That sounds reasonably straightforward.

Until the governance votes enter the picture.

According to Cardanoscan’s record of the proposal, the November 8 snapshot showed just 0.45% support by counted DRep voting power, against a required 67%.

Five DReps had voted yes. Another 109 voted no, while five abstained. The percentage calculation also reflects Cardano’s treatment of voting power that has not voted or is assigned to certain default governance options, rather than simply dividing five votes by the number of participating DReps.

The Constitutional Committee presents an even more immediate obstacle.

Three members—Tingvard, Leandros BSP, and Ace Alliance—had already voted that the proposal was unconstitutional. None had voted to affirm it.

Cardano requires five affirmative votes from the seven-member committee for this type of action.

With three members opposed, even unanimous support from the remaining four would not be enough.

That leaves a narrow mathematical conclusion: unless an existing committee vote changes, the proposal cannot obtain the required constitutional approval.

It has not formally expired. Voting remains open until November 15, and votes can change.

But the opposition is no longer just a matter of sentiment.

The numbers themselves are closing the door.

The First Problem Is What Cardano Would Actually Be Buying

The proposal is framed as a strategic reserve, but only part of the requested money would purchase the commodity.

According to Toto’s published budget, 14,724,409 ADA would buy physical copper.

The remaining 7,275,591 ADA—33.07% of the total—would pay for technology development, warehouse operations, insurance, audits, execution costs, and independent oversight.

That distinction matters because the treasury would be funding both an investment and the infrastructure needed to operate it.

Toto would receive up to 2.64 million ADA for technology development and project management, plus a 441,732 ADA execution fee. Its arrangements also allow for a capped margin on certain third-party invoices.

Under the maximum disclosed fee structure, Toto-related compensation could reach 3,360,023 ADA.

That figure is not equivalent to the company’s net profit. It includes compensation intended to cover development and delivery work, and not every budgeted amount must necessarily be spent.

Nevertheless, the economic arrangement is unusual.

Cardano supplies the capital. Toto develops and administers the system. And while Cardano is supposed to receive the net proceeds from selling its copper reserve, Toto can retain income from its separately funded commercial CuTT activities.

The Cardano Foundation’s published voting rationale identifies this imbalance as one reason for its opposition.

The Foundation isn’t rejecting tokenized commodities as a concept. It questions whether the treasury should finance a concentrated industrial-metal investment while providing development funding and assuming substantial implementation risk.

Its analysis also raises the uncomfortable arithmetic behind the reserve.

If all spending allowances are exhausted, only about two-thirds of the original withdrawal has gone into the asset that must eventually generate the proceeds.

The copper has a considerable amount of ground to make up before Cardano recovers its original ADA.

Copper Needs to Climb 49%. What If ADA Climbs Too?

Toto’s own calculations illustrate the problem.

Using an illustrative purchase price of $6.73 per pound, the proposal estimates that copper would need to reach roughly $10.06 per pound for the treasury to recover the original 22 million ADA, assuming the full budget is spent and ADA’s dollar price stays unchanged.

That’s a gain of about 49%.

But there’s a second variable hiding inside this calculation.

The treasury pays in ADA. Copper trades in dollars. The eventual proceeds must be converted back into ADA.

Those two prices can move in completely different directions.

Consider what happens if ADA appreciates while the copper sits in storage.

Ravel calculated the required copper return using the ratio between the total treasury withdrawal and the copper acquisition budget, then adjusted it for changes in ADA’s dollar price.

The formula is:

Required copper return = (22,000,000 ÷ 14,724,409) × (1 + ADA price change) − 1

With ADA’s dollar price unchanged, copper would need to appreciate 49.4%.

A 20% increase in ADA’s value would push the required copper gain to 79.3%.

Should ADA rise 50%, copper would have to climb roughly 124.1% for the sale proceeds to buy back the original 22 million ADA.

And if ADA doubles, the necessary copper appreciation approaches 198.8%.

These are hypothetical sensitivity calculations, not forecasts. They assume the entire budget is consumed, the amount of purchased copper remains constant, and no additional basis costs or execution differences change the result.

They also work in reverse: a decline in ADA’s dollar price lowers the copper return needed to recover the same number of ADA, although recovering the token count would not necessarily preserve the treasury’s original dollar value.

The important point is that copper can perform well without the treasury recovering its initial ADA.

Toto is effectively asking Cardano to accept exposure to two markets at once, with a substantial cost burden before investment returns can begin.

That doesn’t make the proposal fraudulent or mathematically impossible.

It makes the definition of success considerably more demanding than simply watching copper prices rise.

And then there’s the question of who controls the money while all this happens.

The Wallet Waiting for 22 Million ADA

The governance action identifies a specific reward account as the withdrawal recipient:

stake1uxmfznssgltfuakxlluxdecmu9wwd48kw0pz0qhugaxyjyguc0tax

This is not an address Ravel inferred from unrelated wallet activity. It appears directly in the submitted governance action and is identified in Toto’s proposal as the receiving account.

When Ravel examined the account’s Cardanoscan record on November 8, it controlled just 4.657901 ADA across two associated addresses.

The account had been registered in epoch 661, the same epoch in which Toto submitted its proposal.

Its governance delegation was set to Always Abstain.

Its staking delegation, however, pointed to ST3AK, the Steak.and.ADA stake pool.

That creates an interesting question under Cardano’s treasury rules.

Article II, Section 7(6) of the Cardano Constitution requires treasury funds held by an administrator before further distribution to a withdrawal recipient to remain in auditable, separate accounts. Those funds must use the predefined Abstain governance delegation and must not be delegated to a stake pool operator.

The receiving account satisfies the governance-delegation portion. Its staking delegation does not match the specified restriction.

But that observation needs an important qualification.

The account has not received the proposed 22 million ADA, and Toto is named as both recipient and administrator. The constitutional provision specifically addresses funds held by an administrator before further disbursement to a recipient.

Whether it applies to this precise recipient-administrator arrangement and how Toto would configure custody after approval, requires legal and governance interpretation.

An active stake-pool delegation today is not proof that Toto has already violated the Constitution.

Nor does the small wallet balance establish anything improper. The governance record itself confirms that this withdrawal has not been executed.

The question of who ultimately controls assets on a blockchain has surfaced elsewhere. Ravel’s investigation into Arbitrum’s $30 million intervention showed how protocol-level authority can complicate the familiar assumption that every transfer requires the wallet owner’s signature.

What the account does establish is that Cardano would be transferring a substantial treasury allocation to a recipient-controlled arrangement whose safeguards would become especially important the moment the money arrived.

And the Cardano Foundation has already challenged that structure.

Its voting rationale argues that the full withdrawal would come under Toto’s control before independent custody, oversight, and enforceable protection arrangements were adequately established.

Toto’s proposal promises to put protections in place before relevant asset purchases and token issuance.

That’s a meaningful commitment.

But there is a difference between securing an investment before buying copper and independently controlling 22 million ADA before the funds leave the treasury.

The proposal must survive that distinction.

The technical design adds another layer.

Cardano Pays for Copper. Ethereum Gets the Original Token

Despite being promoted as a Cardano real-world asset initiative, CuTT would initially be minted on Ethereum.

The plan calls for canonical ERC-20 tokens representing verified copper to be issued on Ethereum, locked inside a bridge escrow, and represented by corresponding native assets on Cardano.

The Cardano tokens would be the active, spendable representation of the treasury-funded reserve, while the original Ethereum tokens remained locked.

That means describing Cardano’s allocation as an Ethereum-only product would be misleading.

Cardano would receive a tokenized representation and associated reporting infrastructure.

Still, the architecture creates an additional dependency.

The project needs a functioning Ethereum-to-Cardano bridge, audited smart contracts, accurate supply reconciliation, and an enforceable connection between token holders and the underlying physical reserve.

Those components are implementation milestones, not fully deployed protections.

There is a reasonable explanation for starting on Ethereum.

During an October 27 Cardano Governance Hour discussion, Toto’s representative explained that Ethereum provides access to established real-world asset tracking infrastructure and broader visibility among platforms that already support EVM-based assets.

That’s a commercial argument, not an absurdity.

Ethereum has an established tokenization ecosystem. Using it for issuance and Cardano for the reserve’s active representation could be a deliberate interoperability strategy.

But interoperability doesn’t eliminate counterparty or bridge risk.

It redistributes where those risks sit.

Ravel recently found a related tension in Wall Street’s experiment with tokenized stocks, where building blockchain infrastructure proved easier than securing participation from the companies behind the assets.

Copper doesn’t require an issuer’s consent in the same way a publicly traded stock might. Yet it introduces its own off-chain dependencies: warehouse ownership records, insurance, physical verification, custody, and legal enforcement.

A blockchain can record that a token moved.

It cannot, by itself, guarantee that a warehouse releases the copper represented by that token.

For Cardano’s treasury, this is not a theoretical distinction.

Toto would hold legal title to the physical commodity, while independent collateral arrangements would aim to protect the treasury’s economic interest.

Until Toto establishes those protections and independent parties can verify their effectiveness, token ownership and enforceable claims on the underlying copper remain two different questions.

A Governance Document Became Another Obstacle

The most revealing problem may have nothing to do with commodity prices.

Cardano’s Constitution requires governance proposals to include a document hosted at a URL that cannot be altered after submission.

The purpose is straightforward.

Voters should be able to verify exactly what they are approving without worrying that the underlying document can change halfway through the process.

Toto’s original metadata reference pointed to a document hosted on its own website.

The document includes a cryptographic hash, allowing observers to detect changes. But a matching hash does not necessarily mean the original hosting location is incapable of alteration.

That distinction became a subject of governance criticism.

Toto subsequently published an immutable, content-addressed copy on IPFS.

In its public response to the governance discussion, the company acknowledged that the original on-chain metadata reference remained unchanged.

The new IPFS copy provides a more permanent way to independently verify the document. It does not rewrite the URL already recorded in the governance action.

Critics argue that this leaves the original immutability requirement unresolved.

There is an additional twist.

In its November 6 update, Intersect reported that CAP-9, a proposed constitutional amendment to remove the immutable metadata-storage requirement, had reached its third version on November 3.

In other words, Cardano is considering whether to change the very rule that has become a point of contention in this proposal.

But a draft amendment isn’t an enacted rule.

Even if the community eventually changes the requirement, that would not automatically repair the governance action currently under consideration.

The copper proposal is encountering Cardano’s constitutional safeguards while Cardano is still debating how those safeguards should work.

And none of that requires making a judgment about whether copper is a good investment.

What Would Cardano Actually Lose?

The immediate answer is that the treasury has not lost 22 million ADA.

Cardano has not released the funds under this proposal, and voting remains open.

Toto also deserves credit for disclosing significant risks rather than presenting the investment as a guaranteed return.

The company identifies commodity-price exposure, ADA exchange-rate movements, storage costs, execution risks, and the possibility that the project might fail to recover its original capital.

It promises independent verification, milestone-based acceptance for development work, segregation of funds, and eventual return of the reserve’s net sale proceeds.

Those commitments matter.

But those commitments don’t prove that Toto has already put all the promised safeguards in place.

Meanwhile, the opportunity cost is substantial.

Governance data placed the remaining headroom under Cardano’s current 500 million ADA net change limit at 42,604,371 ADA.

A 22 million ADA withdrawal would consume 51.64% of that remaining withdrawal capacity.

That is not half the entire Cardano treasury. It is more than half the unused room under the applicable spending limit.

The distinction matters because even a successful copper investment would tie up a significant portion of Cardano’s near-term funding flexibility.

Real-world asset tokenization may be an important future market for Cardano.

But demonstrating blockchain infrastructure and placing a concentrated commodity bet are not the same thing.

Neither is paying to develop a private commercial platform nor acquiring a direct economic interest in that platform.

Those are separate decisions, bundled here into one treasury withdrawal.

And the vote suggests that many Cardano representatives remain unconvinced that the combined proposal makes sense.

The Copper Is Still Sitting Outside the Blockchain

With the November 15 deadline approaching, Toto’s proposal faces an obstacle that no bridge contract or copper-price forecast can overcome.

It needs governance approval.

As of the November 8 review, the DRep vote was overwhelmingly against it, and the Constitutional Committee had already recorded enough opposition to prevent approval unless a member changed position.

A resubmitted proposal with different terms could produce a different result.

A smaller pilot, independently controlled custody, completed legal protections, or a different funding structure might answer some of the concerns raised during this process.

The current proposal hasn’t established that those objections are impossible to resolve.

What it has demonstrated is how much more complicated real-world asset tokenization becomes when projects rely on public treasury funds.

The technology can represent a pound of copper as a digital asset. It can track transfers, reconcile token supplies, and publish attestations.

It cannot make 22 million ADA safe simply by labeling the transaction a strategic reserve.

Cardano’s governance process now has to decide whether the proposed economic rights, legal protections, technical architecture, and potential benefits justify the exposure.

For the moment, the answer looks increasingly unlikely to be yes.

Toto hasn’t purchased the copper. It hasn’t issued the tokens. The treasury hasn’t funded the experiment.

But the blockchain has already recorded something consequential.

A project designed to prove that Cardano can bring physical assets on-chain is struggling to prove that Cardano should pay for it.

Muhammad Syofri
Muhammad Syofrihttps://ravelalpha.com/
Syofri is the Editor-in-Chief of RavelAlpha.com and a crypto journalist with more than six years of experience covering digital assets, blockchain, and financial markets. His work focuses on original, data-driven reporting, with a particular interest in on-chain activity, token economics, market narratives, and the fundamentals behind crypto projects. He is especially interested in testing popular crypto narratives against real data and examining what remains when price action and hype are stripped away. Over the years, he has written for both international and Indonesian crypto publications, covering market developments, regulation, emerging blockchain trends, and the people and projects shaping the industry. Outside crypto, Syofri spends his time reading, exploring good food, and playing music.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Popular Articles